Raimondomania hits Sunday NYT as paper lionizes treasurer

October 22nd, 2011 at 1:35 pm by under Nesi's Notes

It’s all about Gina.

Or at least The New York Times’ Sunday Business cover piece on Rhode Island’s finances sure is. The glowing 2,500-word profile of the state treasurer and her one-woman crusade to overhaul the state pension system never mentions Gov. Lincoln Chafee’s name, let alone those of the House speaker and Senate president.

Times reporter Mary Williams Walsh’s contribution to the rising tide of Raimondomania forges no new ground when it comes to Rhode Island’s intertwined public-finance crises, though she makes a good analogy between the state and General Motors, noting both strained their pension systems with rounds of layoffs.

Here’s Walsh’s thesis, in a nutshell:

All of this might seem small in the scheme of national affairs. After all, this is Little Rhody (population: 1,052,567). But the nightmare scenario is that Ms. Raimondo has seen the future of America, and it is Rhode Island. As Wall Street fixates on the financial disaster in Greece, a fiscal wreck is playing out right here. And the odds are that it won’t be the last. Before this is over, many Americans may be forced to rethink what government means at the state and local level.

The Times piece includes a few minor points worth correcting for the sake of the historical record:

1. Walsh writes that Raimondo “stood out” during last year’s election “because she refused to promise that state jobs and pension benefits would be protected.” Actually, what really stood out was her eye-popping fundraising prowess, as Tim White reported last year.

2. Walsh notes the Raimondo-chaired state Retirement Board’s April vote to lower the pension fund’s investment return forecast from 8.25% to 7.5%, and says: “As a result of that change, the state’s pension shortfall instantly rose to $9 billion from $7 billion.” Not quite.

First off, the investment return change (which does get most of the attention) actually wasn’t the sole reason the pension liability exploded, as both Raimondo and the NEARI’s Robert Walsh have repeatedly pointed out. The state’s actuary also prepared new mortality tables and wage forecasts that played a big part in the increase.

Second, the pension shortfall instantly rose not from $7 billion to $9 billion but from $4.9 billion to $7.3 billion. The Times’ Walsh may be confusing the $7.3 billion shortfall in the state-run pension system and the $2.1 billion shortfall in the 36 locally run pension systems, which combine to $9.4 billion, as explained on WPRI 12′s newscast Tuesday night.

3. Finally – a small one, but Walsh implies that the Providence library system “lost its financing from the city in 2009, closed branches and shortened its hours.”

What actually happened is Mayor Cicilline shifted the city appropriation from the Providence Public Library to the new Providence Community Library in order to stop branches from closing and slashing their hours, as PPL wanted to do. If anything, the new PCL’s ability to maintain library services in a time of austerity is a counterpoint to Walsh’s broader argument.

(screenshot: NYTimes.com)

Tags: , , , ,

10 Responses to “Raimondomania hits Sunday NYT as paper lionizes treasurer”

  1. Pat Crowley says:

    Facts? We don’t need no stinkin facts…..we’re the New York Times!

    1. Ted Nesi says:

      You’d think having a paywall would make you try harder! You get what you pay for at Nesi’s Notes.

  2. [...] R.I. (WPRI) – Treasurer Gina Raimondo doesn’t sound thrilled about her growing national reputation as an anti-pension warrior aiming to smash Rhode Island’s public-sector [...]

  3. [...] to Rhode Island. Here’s some fact-checking of the NYT story from a local journalist, Ted Nesi: 2. Walsh notes the Raimondo-chaired state Retirement Board’s [...]

  4. [...] governor’s reform package,” a quite different take from The New York Times, which made no mention of Chafee in a 2,500-word story on Rhode Island’s pension debate that ran [...]

  5. Al Moncrief says:

    Ted I think you have a better understanding of public sector defined benefit plans than does the author of the Times piece. In addition to factual errors I noted a bias in the piece.

    1. Ted Nesi says:

      Thanks, Al, but in fairness to Ms. Walsh, she has to keep track of 50 state pension systems and I only have to know one.

      1. Al Moncrief says:

        Hey Ted, actually I think there are about 90? public pension plans where the state is the plan sponsor, and who knows how many local government sponsored plans. I saw a list once, it would be interesting to look again.

        What will be the next public policy arena for Ted to become immersed in, as the pension issue languishes in court?

      2. Ted Nesi says:

        Good point. Not sure what’s next for me after pensions (still seems a long way away), but considering 2012 is a campaign year, I bet I won’t lack for assignments!

  6. Gary Arnold says:

    Unless people are living in a hole (in RI) they should be applauding Gina R for stopping the can from being kicked down the road, again. We are in a critical problem caused by the incompetent lawmakers and their collusive union brothers.
    I am totally surprised that union member retirees are not at war with their unions for not putting up some of the BILLIONS they have collected in dues and for tax payers for not demanding that political collusion with the unions should negate their pensions, including the double dippers.