Union: Providence Journal plans more staff cuts this month

September 7th, 2012 at 11:11 am by under Nesi's Notes, On the Main Site

By Ted Nesi

PROVIDENCE, R.I. (WPRI) – The Providence Journal will cut an undetermined number of employees this month through buyouts or layoffs, according to the largest union at Rhode Island’s statewide daily.

The Providence Newspaper Guild said Friday management has told union officials the paper will offer “a new round of buyouts, and warned layoffs are possible if enough employees don’t accept them.”

The deadline for workers to request a buyout is Monday, Sept. 17. Eligibility will be determined by seniority, though exceptions may be made for workers in key jobs. The Journal’s work force fell by a third to 468 employees between 2008 and 2011.

Union president John Hill told WPRI.com he’s pressed executives to put a specific number on how many staff members they need to shed, but Journal management has only told him they want “significantly more” than the eight cuts they targeted in last December’s buyout round.

That “is making it difficult for us,” Hill said. “A number would help us communicate the seriousness, the magnitude of what we’re confronting.” Journal publisher Howard Sutton did not respond to a request for comment.

It’s unclear what will happen if management doesn’t get enough voluntary buyouts. “The answer is, until Sept. 17, we don’t know,” the Guild said in its unsigned message. “This is a step-by-step process and we are in the first one.”

The union has asked its members to show “compassion” toward their colleagues. “This situation is going to make for a difficult few weeks. It will involve hard, life-changing decisions for those who are considering leaving and anxiety about the future for those who fear a layoff,” the union said. The Guild signed a new contract last year.

“If you’re in the newspaper business [today] you always see it coming – this is all you think about,” Hill said. “Nationally, this is happening all over the country. Everybody is worried this kind of thing is coming, so in a way it is unfortunately not a total surprise. You always hope you’ve got enough going to sort of stagger through.”

Employees who accept the buyout will receive 1.25 weeks of base pay for each continuous year of service at The Journal, capped at 10 weeks, according to the Guild. They will also receive a supplemental pension transition payment by next year, the union said. Employees are especially concerned about the lack of extended health insurance coverage, Hill said.

The Journal’s total revenue rose to $46.7 million during the first six months of 2012, an increase of 1.3% compared with the first half of 2011, its Dallas-based parent company A.H. Belo reported last month. The paper’s advertising revenue plunged 61% between 2005 and 2011.

Hill said Rhode Island’s continued economic weakness is a major contributor to the reduction in ad sales, and expressed hope that a stronger national upturn next year could lift the state’s economy, as well.

“You can only put out a newspaper that the advertising revenue you generate can support,” he said. “Hold the paper – you can see how thick it is. It is not because they decided they’re going to put out a thinner paper. … They’re doing it because this is the paper that the economic base that we have can support at this moment.”

The Journal’s weekday print circulation fell to 85,496 copies a day in the six months ended March 31, down 7% from a year earlier, according to the Audit Bureau of Circulations. The paper put up a paywall in February after limiting its HTML site to short news briefs and sold 273 electronic-edition subscriptions as of March.

The Journal is dealing with the same seismic changes in the newspaper industry that have impacted other outlets from The New York Times to the Newport Daily News. The New Orleans Times-Picayune has announced it will lay off staff and cut its print-publication schedule down to three days a week starting this fall.

The Journal continues to have Rhode Island’s biggest newsroom. Hill pointed out its three-person State House bureau is the only team left there, and the paper has also put significant resources into recent coverage of topics such as the economy, pensions and Central Falls’ bankruptcy.

“Everything that people talk about in this state, they learn from The Providence Journal,” he said. “I have never lived in a state where I think the newspaper is so embedded in the fabric of public life. … The only way people really find out what’s going on up there [at the State House] is our people telling them.”

“There’s just so much that no one else pays attention to if we’re not there, and no one would know what’s going on,” Hill added. “I can’t conceive of a Rhode Island without The Providence Journal. But if people don’t buy the paper, they may have to someday.”

M. Charles Bakst, the former Journal columnist who accepted a buyout in 2008 after four decades at the paper, said he has “no complaints whatsoever” after “a long and gratifying career” there, but expressed concern that others won’t have the opportunity to enjoy similarly long careers.

“And when staff is reduced, quality suffers and readers lose,” Bakst told WPRI.com in an email. “Websites are a great invention and I appreciate them, but it is important to understand that websites will not be able to offer the same kind of content they have been if reporters are not available to produce the stories in the first place. Not to mention the work of photographers or other personnel.”

“This is, in our nation, a very challenging and sad time for print journalism,” Bakst added. “People should savor their newspapers while they still have them.”

Ted Nesi ( tnesi@wpri.com ) covers politics and the economy for WPRI.com and writes the Nesi’s Notes blog. Follow him on Twitter: @tednesi

• Related: Projo parent AH Belo’s board awards big raises to top bosses (March 20)

This post has been updated and expanded.

Tags: , ,

21 Responses to “Union: Providence Journal plans more staff cuts this month”

  1. Ed says:

    Who reads the Providence Journal anymore. I used to love to read the paper. For the last 5 or six years all the stories have been minor or from various news services. When the projo drops the price and gets hard hitting stories then I will buy the paper. The paper at this time is not worth $1 per day or $3.00 on Sundays.

    1. Geoff says:

      I use my 20% coupon from CVS to buy my saturday PROJO paper or I don’t buy it at all..lol

      On Sundays i just hope and pray I get 3.00 worth of coupons to make the paper worthwhile…

      1. Ed says:

        Most coupons on high profit items. Stay with the basics.

  2. Future Former Rhode Islander says:

    Politi”fact” today was a laff-riot. “We find that Cicilline was truthful in that the City Auditor was not actually ‘locked out’ with a lock, as such.” What next? “We find that Cicilline was truthful in that the City Auditor was not actually ‘frozen out’ as in encased in ice, or in carbonite, or in another cold substance.” The city is better off without ProJo’s ridiculousness.

  3. Future Former Rhode Islander says:

    But I’m sorry for anyone losing their jobs.

  4. Alex Burk says:

    If you follow this issue, check out the new book “Dying Breed: The True Story of How the Internet Killed My Career as a Newspaper Reporter”

  5. John says:

    The Journal should take this situation seriously enough to eliminate non essential jobs first. I personally feel that Michael Janusonis should be one of the first cuts made. The Journal could save some serious money on his Dining Out budget alone. His visits each week to high end food establishments just to satisfy his craving for the same drinks and seafood week after week is ridiculous. In addition, his movie reviews are boring and uninteresting. They could easily be replaced with standard reviews that appear and are available from leading newspapers.

    1. Ed says:

      John, Rhode Island is only known for so many pasta joints. I can make pasta at home. I don’t need to be served frozen food from Venda Ravoli that is served in most pasta joints in Rhode Island.

      1. John says:

        I agree with you. Anyone who reads the weekly Dining Out Restaurant feature knows that it is only a self serving column that enables Mr. Janusonis the opportunity to enjoy his cocktails and highly expensive dinners with a dining companion on the Journal tab. No one could afford to spend on food what he enjoys eating at these establishments (almost always seafood) week after week. Suprisingly, no one cares at the Journal. Unfortunately, some hard working employee will be eliminated. Really sad.

  6. Dave says:

    Coming from a one-time newspaper reporter, it is unfortunate that the Projo, which is certainly a Rhode Island staple, is struggling. But the fact of the matter remains that it is not at influential as it once was. The reason is top talent, such as Ted Nesi, Tim White, Ian Donnis, etc. have built strong reputations, rightfully so, in their careers in TV, radio and new media. (And Nesi and Donnis got their start in the newspaper business!)

    Unless John Hill has worked in 25-30 states he is making quite a sweeping generalization to say, “Everything that people talk about in this state, they learn from The Providence Journal. I have never lived in a state where I think the newspaper is so embedded in the fabric of public life. … The only way people really find out what’s going on up there [at the State House] is our people telling them.”

    John has to wake up and realize people are going to Nesi’s Notes, WPRI, WRNI, and different blog sites to get news that is happening at the State House that is not being reported by the Projo. Those outlets are succeeding because they are consistently producing better stories. Period.

    1. Future Former Rhode Islander says:

      Exactly! I’d buy Projo or its online service if it was consistently good, but it’s consistently bad. I’ve learned that there are much better sources of real news coverage & serious analysis.

      1. Ed says:

        Future former RI’er. I concur with you once the housing market gets to more realistic prices, we are out of this outhouse. The people of Rhode Island allow their government to stink to high heaven. It is time the state house get a giant eneama.

  7. [...] WPRI | Providence Newspaper Guild The Providence Journal will offer buyouts to employees and impose layoffs if it doesn’t get enough takers, Ted Nesi reports. Employees have until Sept. 17 to volunteer; their last day at work will be Sept.… Read more [...]

  8. [...] WPRI | Providence Newspaper Guild The Providence Journal will offer buyouts to employees and impose layoffs if it doesn’t get enough takers, Ted Nesi reports. Employees have until Sept. 17 to volunteer; their last day at work will be Sept.… Read more Share this: Tweet this! [...]

  9. [...] There’s no silver lining to The Providence Journal’s decision to cut its staff again – as Charlie Bakst points out in my story, it’s bad news for journalism and bad news [...]

  10. Angelisagreatdog says:

    National studies have shown that more than 80 percent of all news circulated on all media originates from newspapers. RI’s tv stations each have a few reporters. Ditto radio stations, tho even less. As for restaurant reviews, hospitality is a big economic factor here. Even during the recession, people continued to eat out. They want to know what new restaurants are like before they slap down $100, which plenty of people appear to be willing to do. This is consumer news that plenty of people use, and both Janusonis and food editor Gail Ciampa do them.

    1. John says:

      The restaurants visited by Mr. Janusonis are only self serving. This is quite evident if you read them week after week. Many are not new restaurants. They all follow his same pattern. I enjoy the columns by Mrs. Ciampa. Many are different and often reasonable. It takes a lot more money than $100 to eat at most of the establishments reviewed by Mr. Janusonis. He only tries the highest priced dishes and, of course, anything to do with seafood. The Journal could save a lot of money by diversifying the reviewers and/or eliminating his position. Save the job of someone who really matters.

  11. Jon paycheck says:

    With all the corruption and mismanagement
    In this state, any reporter could have won a Pulitzer
    Prize every year.

    Most , but not all , at the projo and other papers are lazy and go for quick sound bites.

    There are Few real journalists left with any
    Objectivity. ( evidence – barack Obama was nothing
    More than a media hoax)

    The only thing you can believe in any paper is
    The date.

    Wpri 12 has passed wjar and projo, they work harder.

  12. Bob says:

    It would be a disaster if the Journal went under. With so many boarded up businesses here, it wouldn’t surprise.
    The only new businesses I see opening up consistently are banks.

  13. [...] the company moves forward with layoffs. Employees must volunteer to take the buyout by Monday and layoffs could follow depending on the [...]

  14. [...] eight buyouts would be enough to prevent layoffs at The Journal, which the paper’s management says will be required if too few employees leave voluntarily. Guild president John Hill was not immediately available for [...]