The Saturday Morning Post: Quick hits on politics & more in RI
Welcome to another edition of my weekend column, back on schedule after a one-week blizzard outage. As always, send your takes, tips and trial balloons to tnesi@wpri.com. For quick hits all week long, follow me on Twitter: @tednesi.
1. Scituate’s police pension fiasco is a great illustration of why governments should pay for pension benefits when they’re earned, not when they’re collected. As Josh Barro has explained at length, pensions are a component of employee compensation, and therefore their cost should be covered when the worker is doing whatever job is earning him or her the future benefit. (Think about how your employer puts money into your 401k account with each paycheck.) For obvious reasons current taxpayers seem to prefer promising pensions now but sticking the bill with future taxpayers – it keeps taxes lower. That, however, is neither fair nor sustainable. As we’re seeing, current taxpayers don’t want to pay for promises that someone else made decades ago, especially if they’re dissatisfied with current services. And who can blame them? In addition, the principle of pre-funding is even more important if pensions are an unchangeable contract, as the unions argue in their current lawsuit. Barro thinks politicians just can’t be trusted with defined-benefit pensions, and therefore everyone should move to 401k-style systems. Others – including Dean Baker and, to a lesser extent, Gina Raimondo – say those defined-contribution systems are inadequate and unnecessarily expensive. Perhaps there’s a middle ground that pension traditionalists can get behind: if the law requires pension benefits to be paid in full, the law should require that pension contributions be made in full, too.
2. This will get people talking: Jack Reed, Sheldon Whitehouse, Jim Langevin, David Cicilline and Patrick Kennedy are co-hosting a breakfast fundraiser for Lincoln Chafee on Monday, Feb. 25 at Peck Madigan Jones, a lobbying firm in Washington. Longtime Clinton confidante Harold Ickes is among those on the host committee. The fact that the all-Democratic congressional delegation is raising money for the independent governor doesn’t necessarily mean he’ll be joining their party; rather, it may mean he’s preparing to splinter the Democratic Party for a second election cycle in a row. I wonder what Gina Raimondo and Angel Taveras think?
3. Speaking of Mayor Taveras, I talked with him a few days ago about his energetic use of Twitter to figure out which streets needed the most plowing after the blizzard. “I think people really appreciated it, to be honest with you,” he said. “They want to know that help is on the way, that their complaint has been heard and somebody’s going to do something about it.” Taveras demurred when I asked how much sleep he got during and after the storm: “It’s amazing what the human body can do when it needs to do some of these things.” Having a newborn baby was probably good preparation.
4. Rhode Island’s leaders have a new Public Enemy No. 1: plastic bags. Barrington has banned them, and now Providence Rep. Maria Cimini wants to do the same. But is this bit of feel-good policymaking actually bad for public health? That’s what National Review’s Ramesh Ponnuru says, arguing the bag bans have inadvertently caused outbreaks of diarrhea, nausea and E. coli. “The best course for government,” he writes, “is probably to encourage people to recycle their plastic bags – or, maybe, just let people make their own decisions.”
5. I recently finished Matt Yglesias’ urbanist manifesto “The Rent is Too Damn High,” and its lessons are highly applicable to Rhode Island, which is the second-densest state and plagued by high housing costs. Yglesias argues that places where land is expensive should be densely built “to ensure office and apartment rents stay reasonable.” He continues: “It’s absurd for many urban areas to suffer chronic shortfalls of affordable housing. Undistinguished structures should, if built on expensive land, be torn down and replaced by substantially taller ones, and vacant lots should be built up to as much density as the market can bear. If people have strong feelings about not wanting to live on the same block as a tall building, they can move or they can pay what it costs to make it worth a neighboring property owner’s while to avoid building taller. Using regulatory fiat to curb construction rather than bearing the cost directly doesn’t change the fact that there’s a price to be paid for using the land inefficiently. It merely pushes the costs elsewhere.” That, Rhode Islanders, is a big reason why your rents (and mortgages) are too damn high.
6. What went wrong at the polls last November? Common Cause Rhode Island’s John Marion tackles that question in an extensive new report that should be required reading for the Board of Elections and the General Assembly. The question, as always, is whether lawmakers really want to improve how the state runs its elections – since, by definition, they’re pleased with the results from last time.
7. “Life and Times: Episodes 1-4″ is a new “postmodern pop opera” that relates the “epic journey through the addled memory bank of a young woman growing up in middle-class Rhode Island.” How about that? It recently finished a run at New York’s Public Theatre, and I hope the seats are comfortable: the show is eight hours long. Who’ll perform it in Providence?
8. A loyal Saturday Morning Post reader points us to a new documentary called “The Last Gladiators,” which chronicles the career of famed pro-hockey enforcer Chris Nilan. Some of you may remember “Nuckles” Nilan making headlines locally about a decade ago when he was forced out of a part-time gig with Secretary of State Ed Inman for allegedly working less-than-regular hours. Matt Brown made Nilan into a campaign issue when he successfully challenged Inman in 2002.
9. Did you catch Tim White’s story Thursday night about testing anxiety in Rhode Island schools? Watch it here, and then read Dan McGowan’s stunning sidebar revealing that 40% of high-school juniors are in danger of failing to graduate.
10. The £400m fine Royal Bank of Scotland will pay for manipulating Libor has renewed speculation about whether the bank will sell its profitable Providence-based Citizens Financial division. Count New Statesman columnist Douglas Blakey among those who think the British government should “stop pussyfooting about” the much-debated decision and just pull the trigger. “RBS will, eventually, have to bow to the inevitable and cash in its Citizens chips,” Blakey wrote last week. “It is now time for the government, via UK Financial Investments Limited, the organisation set up immediately after the October 2008 bailouts of Lloyds and RBS, to bear its teeth. It could start by leaning heavily on RBS to focus on getting its domestic market in order and sell off Citizens.” What would that mean for Rhode Island?
11. My grandfather and namesake, retired Attleboro District Court Judge Edward A. Lee, died Thursday at the age of 92. He was a quintessential member of Brokaw’s Greatest Generation. Papa Ed grew up in Attleboro between the wars, the son of devout Irish Catholic immigrants without much money but with a strong belief in education. He signed a minor-league baseball contract with a Boston Braves affiliate in 1942, but World War II derailed that; Providence College actually moved his graduation up from June 1943 to December 1942 so he and his classmates could enter the military sooner. After serving in Europe under Lt. Gen. William Simpson, he got his law degree from Georgetown and then came back to Attleboro, got married and grew into a pillar of the community. Governor Foster Furcolo appointed him to the bench in 1957 (even though, being Irish, Papa Ed was a Kennedy man), which made him the court’s youngest judge at just 36. I associate my grandfather most with two beloved civic institutions: the Attleboro Public Library, which he led as president of the trustees from 1979 to 2012, and the Attleboro YMCA, where he exercised faithfully until he was nearly 90. Papa Ed was flawed, as all of us are, but he was devoted to his family and his community. Gentle and smart, a history buff, he was everlastingly supportive of his eldest grandson. I love him dearly, and I miss him already.
12. Set your DVRs: This week on Newsmakers – Education Commissioner Deborah Gist. Watch Sunday at 10 a.m. on Fox Providence. This week on Executive Suite – Providence Mutual Insurance CEO Sandra Parrillo. Watch Saturday at 10:30 p.m. or Sunday at 6 p.m. on myRITV (or Sunday at 6 a.m. on Fox). See you back here next Saturday morning.
Ted Nesi ( tnesi@wpri.com ) covers politics and the economy for WPRI.com and writes the Nesi’s Notes blog. Follow him on Twitter: @tednesi
Tags: saturday quick hits
If Tavares can’t handle a snow storm, how in Gods name can he go ask the voters of Rhode Island to give him a vote for Governor ??????
If he runs, all his opponent/ opponents have to do is refresh the minds of his disastrous leadership in the storm……
Dino C sounds like he works in the Gina for Gov office. My Providence streets were fine.
If your streets were fine, I think we know who works in ones office.
chaffee’s biggest problem will be that after 4 years in office, most voters realize they arent voting for his father.
he got 36% last time and he has lost all state workers and union support that was his base 2 years ago.
his buddy obama will finally be acknowledged as a total bust in 2 years.
and raimondo will move to the left as much as chafee.
taveras and raimondo are much more politically astute than doherty, so dont think linc can pull a ciccilni
i cant see him getting more than 25% of the vote
Put four or more Democrats in a primary…. Almonte could come out with the W.
regarding #2 – the same whores will have parties for raimondo and taveras.they just havetn scheduled the dattes yet.
very sad, money in dc is ruining this country and the congress and president do nothing about it. no wonder approval is so low.
What a nice tribute to your grandfather! Both of my “greatest generation” grandfathers also died in their 90s and while I miss them terribly, I know how fortunate I was to grow up knowing them as well as I did and having the opportunity to learn so much from them. I hope that the good memories of your time together help see you through this sad time.
Ted, did you even read the anti-bag ban column you referred to let alone the articled linked in it as evidence that “bans lead to ecoli”? Teenagers storing food in a bathroom is a really bad idea no matter what material the bag is made of. There are many be a whole host of reasons to oppose a plastic bag moratorium. But fear mongering about intestinal disorders is simply parroting the industry’s desperation. Food safety and common sense are what keeps people healthy not cheap, hyrdrocarbon based, films of plastic.
#1: Yes. If there were more than a dozen people in this state that understood that, we might have hope. Still, it’s nice to see someone else explain it for a change.
#4: People can have my plastic bags when they come over to clean my cat’s litter box.
#5: This is why our towns should have a land value tax rather than a property tax. The switch-over would be easy, the new tax wouldn’t be any less fair, but the gains from the change between what we are currently discouraging to what we would be discouraging would be immense. Yglesias probably mentions it; I wouldn’t know.
…and I’m sorry about #11.
Ted, sorry for your loss. Your grandfather sounds like a great man and you were blessed to have him in your life.
[...] Island’s leaders have a new Public Enemy No. 1: plastic bags,” proclaims WPRI blogger Ted Nesi. “But is this bit of feel-good policymaking actually bad for public [...]
[...] Island’s all-Democratic congressional delegation hosted a fundraiser for Chafee in Washington on Monday morning, and Chafee and his wife served on the host committee for U.S. Sen. [...]